Escaping the Bully-God of American Evangelicalism: An Interview with Doug Frank - The Other Journal

But I see myself on the cross too. Beneath all of my posturing and image-tending, I’m a body, finite and frail, suffering life’s wounds and indignities. How many times in a single day do I feel abandoned, insufficient, or ridiculous in the eyes of others? This is a condition the spirit of God shares…

— Doug Frank, theotherjournal.com

Religion jesus Shame

There’s so much pressure to be good and holy that we get scared of all the parts of us that aren’t.

— Doug Frank, theotherjournal.com

Religion Evangelicalism

Very often God seems to come in moments of failure or shame. For example, Father Zossima tells how in his youth, for no good reason, he savagely beat his orderly. The next morning he sees with utter clarity that he has beaten a helpless, innocent man. He’s overwhelmed with sorrow and shame, and he b…

— Doug Frank, theotherjournal.com

The Brothers Karamosov Why people are such dicks

When I talked with students who were trying to get as far as they could from their childhood religion, they often confessed to feeling guilty or ashamed about their rebellion. I would say thank God—thank some better God—for your rebelliousness. It’s a cry of truth from inside you. It’s a kind of pro…

— Doug Frank, theotherjournal.com

Religion Evangelicalism Doubt Faith

For me, and for a lot of the Christian college students I’ve gotten to know over the years, the constant pressure to love God and to be a certain way for God leads you to judge yourself a spiritual failure. It’s never God’s fault that you don’t feel close. Preachers will say ‘God is always reaching…

— Doug Frank, theotherjournal.com

Religion Spirituality God Spiritual abuse Evangelicalism

&&MK KK K MWWWWWWWWWWWWWWK&W MWWWWMMWWWWWWWWWWWWWMK WWKKWWWWMK&MWWWWWWWWMWMM WW &WWWWWWWWMMWWWWWWWMWWM&& W&K&WWWWWWWWMMWWWWWWWWWWMMMK WWWMWM&&K&WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM& KK MWW WWWWWWWWWWWWWWMWM&KK MM WWWWWM WWWWW MWWWWWWWWWWWWMMMMM& KMW MW MWWW KWWWWWWMWWWWWWWWWWWWWWMMM&&&& K WWWW WWWWWM KWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&&&&&M&KMWWWWW&MWWWWKWW KWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&&KK &MM&&KWWWW KWWWW& WW WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&KKKK KK&MMWMMWWWKWW W WW KW WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&MMMMM&K&K&MMWWWWWWWWW MMW M &M &&WWWWWWWWWWWMMMMMWM&&K&MMMM&MWWWWWW&&WWW KWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWMMWWMM&&KK&&MM&&&&KKWWWWWWM WWWWWWWWWWWWWWMMWWWWMM&&&&&&&KKKK WWWWWK MM WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&&KKKK KM& &W WWM && KK KWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&&K WWWW &WK MW &WWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&KK WWK M K&&K WW & KWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&KK &WWMK MK MM MMM&KMK&K& WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWMM&KKK &WWMK K KWWWWWWWWWWMKKK MK KK &WK KWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWMM&&KK KWWWW& MK &WWMWWWKK& &MK K K K KKK WW& MWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&K KMWWWW&K & &&KKWWMWW &&M MMM K WW WWWWWWWWWWWWWWM&&K &WWWWW&&K KM &&&& &WWW& & WK& WWK WWWWWWWWWWMM&KK &WWWWWM& &K KWMMK K WWMM &K &&K K WWW& &WWWWWWM&&KK K&WWWWWWWMWM K&W K &&&K K K &WM KK K W WW& KWWWWWMMK K&MMWWWWWWWW&&M&K&KMWK K & KWWWM WWM MWMM& KK&MMWWWWWWW&&&WMKKK KWWK K& &&M K KWW WWWWW WWWM KMMMMMWWWWWWWWWW&KKMKKKKK WWK& W& MMK WWWW & MWWWM K &MWWWWWWWWWWWWWW&KKK&K &WMK& W KM KM&KK KMMW& WWW MWWWWK &WWWWWWWWWWWW&&KK&K K&K M&M& K& K&W& M&MWWWWWWWMWW WWWW WWW WWWWWWWWW&KKKK & MWK W &WWMWWWMWWWWWWWWW&&M

,.,,,..,,,.,,,,:::,: :,:,:: : : :::: .,. ,: .,, :, , ,: . , .. . , ::,,. .,,,,,,,.,,,,,:,::: :::::: :: : : : . ,. .. ,, .: .. : :,:, ,,,,:,,,,.,,:,::,,::: : ,:,,:: : :: :: :,: ,,. ., .: , . . ,. . ::,. ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,:::: : : ,: ,: : : ,:, : : :::. , , : . . : ,: ,,:,::,.,,,:,::,:: : ::,,:: ::: , ., . , . :. :: ,,::::::,,,,,:,,::: :: :::. : : : :, , .. , , : ::::::,,,::,:::::: :::,,, : : ,:: ,:: :: ... . . : ,:::::,:,,,:,,::::: : ::,:,:: : : : , : , :::::::::,,,,::::::::: :::,:: , :::::::::,:::,::, : : ::,,:::: : , ::: ::::,:,:,:,,,::: : : :, : ,. ::: :::,:,,,,,::: : ::: . :. .. ::: :::,:,.,,,,::: : :: : .. . : : ::::,,,,,,,,:, : :: , :::::,,,,,,,,,,,::: : :: . , ,::::::,,,,,,,,:, :: : : ::::::,,,:,,,,,::::: : : . , :, :,,,:,,,: :::: : ., :::::::,,,,,:,:,::: :: : : , : ::::,:,,,,,,::: : : : ,,., :: :::,,,,:::::: : : , : : ::::::,:::: : : :, : . . : : :::::::::: : :: , , , :, : . : ::: , : :: . , , : ::, : : :: : : : . :: , : ::: : . , :.., , : : , ,.. , :: : . , : : : :: :,.. ,:, . . . : : :.. :,,,. :. . .:: : . , : :...... , : . .: : :: ,.. . : :.,,., . ,, : . :. , . .,, . : , . . . .. : . . . :: ... . . :,. . . . : . .,, . , . , , . . , . ,:...., . ., : , .,,: ,.. ,:. .,: . . , , . .,,.. , , . .: :: . : : , : .., ,

~~~~ ~ ~~<~~ ~~~~<<<<<~<~~~~~ ~~~~~<<~<<~<*****<*<~<<<<<<****~< <~}~** } * << *~ }}*<<<<<~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~<~<<<<<~<< ~<~~ ~~<~<*~*<**<<<<****<<<~<~<<}***<}<<~*<**~~<<*<~*<} ~ *< ~ *} } }}*<<<*~<<<~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~<~~~ ~~~<<<<*<<~<<<~~~~~~<~<<*<<*<*<<}*<**<~<~~~~~<***<* } << * * << ~ * *~ ~ << }** * < }}**<*<<<<<~~~~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~<<<<<<<<<<~~<<<~<~<<***<*<***<****<*<<~~~ <<***<* } } ~ *}} ~~* ~ ~ <~ }}****<**<~<~~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~*<*<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<*<*}**}**}****}<<<~~~~<**<*** ~ } < <** < ~ }***<<*<*<<<<~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~<~ ~~~~<<****<<<<<<**<<<****}*}*}*}}}}*****<< ~<<~*****} } ~ ~ ~* * }********<*<<<~~ ~~~~~ ~~~<~~ ~ ~~~<*<**<<<*<<<**~<<****}}*}}}}}}******<<~~<<*****<~ }~ < } }****}*}****<<<~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~<*******<***<*<***}}}} }} } }}}}}**<~~<~<<**}** < <} < } **}** }}}***<<~~ ~ ~~~<~~~~~~~~<***<**********}**}*} *}} }}}} }**<<~~**}*}}<} }}<~ < } }}}*}}* *}<**<~< ~ ~ ~ ~<<<<~ <~<<**}}*<<***}}}***}}}}} } } }}}}*}<*<*<*}}}}~ * }}} }} }**<<~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~<~~<<<~~~~<<**}*}}}*}}*}}*}}}*} } } }}***<<**}} } ~ }}}} } }}**}<~ ~ ~~~ ~~~ ~~~~<*<~~<<<<<*}*}}}}}**}}*}*} }} }} }}}}<*}}} }}~ } ~ < } }}* <<~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~~~~~~<<*<<<<**}} }}*}}}*}}}*}} } }}*}*}}}<~ * } }***< ~ ~ ~<~~ ~~~~~~<<~*<<<<*<*}} } }*}}}}}}}}}* } }}****<~ ~ < }}}<< ~ ~<<~ ~~~*****<*<**}} } }}}}}}}}}** } }}}*~ < }}}*< ~~~~ ~ ~ <<<<<*<******} }*}* }}}}}*}} } }}< ~ }*< ~ ~~~~~~ <<*}<*<**}}} } } } }}*}} } }}}< ~ } }*< ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~ ~~*<**<****}}* }} }*}}}} *< } *<< ~ ~ ~ ~~<<*<**}****} } } }} }}}} }*< ~ ~ } }}< ~ ~~ ~~~~ ~ ~~<<<*<****}} } * } } }}}} } } }}} ~ * }** ~~~ ~ ~~~~ ~ ~<<<**}****}}}} }}} } }}**} }* } } ~ * }< ~~~~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~~~<<**}*}***}} }}* *~< }} ** * } ~ * }< ~ ~< ~ ~ ~~~~~~<<<<<**}****}}} }}}} }< *< ~ ~ } }} ~ *~ ~ ** ~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~<~<<~~~<<<<*****<***}} }}} } }~}< }<* ~ ~ < * }* ~ ~<~~ ~~ ~ ~~~~<<<<<~<<~<<<*<<***<*}*}} *< < < < }~ * }<~ ~ ~ *~ * }* ~~ <~~~ ~~ ~<~<<<<<<<<~<<<<<*****}*} }<~ } } * ~~~<~~~~ ~~ ~<<~<<<**<<*<<**}* }*< }~ < < * ~ }* ~~<<~ ~ ~ ~<<<<<*<***}** }< } ~ }~ ~ * <} * <~~<<~~~~ <~ ~<*<*< } }* * < < ~ } <~<<<~~~~<<<}*<** << < * }<* ~ ** <<<<~<<<~ ~ * ~< }~ <} * ** < ~~ ~ ~ < } }* <<<< * ~ }~ ~ < }~ <<~ } ~< * *< }}* <<<< } ~<< *<~ ~~ * < < ~ ~ < < } }* <*<*< ~**} } < * ~* } ~ }}* <<<<<*~ *< ~~<} } }} ~ < ~ * * } ~ }< <<**<<<*<<****}*}*****}}<******}}}}}} } ~ << * * < ** * << ~ ~ ** * **

j o VjjVoj j jj U joooo j j j jj j Uj j ooooo V Vo o V o oooooo j j o joVVojj V oVV oVVojj o Uo o oVVojj j j jj U Uo j oo VVoo j j j jjjj j V VUoj oooj jj jjj j ojjj V UVjjV VVojj jjjj j jjjj jojjjjjj j j V o V UU oVo j jjjj j jjjjjjjojjjj j j j o o UU o V oVjjjjjjjjoj j jj jj jjjjjojjjjjjjjjj Uo U U jooj jojjjjjjj j jj jj jjjjojjjjjjjjjj ojoojojooojjj j jj jjjjjjjjooojoojj jjj j UUU oo V oVoojojojoojj jjojj j j jjjoojojojjjjjjjj UU U U V j ooojooooooojojj joo j j jojj jj jjojoooooooojjj U U VU VVVooVoooo ojjj jooojjj jj jjjjojooooooojjjjjjjj o o VVVoVVooooojojj j ojooj j j jjjjjoooooooVjooooojjjj oV VVVVVVVoooojjjj joojo jj j jj j jjj jjooooooooooojj jj j U VVVVoVVVVVooojoj joooojj j j j oooVVVVoVVVVVojj j U UUVVj o UUUVVVVVVVoooooojj oooojjj jjj Ujj Voj ojj jU U UUUUVojjoU UUUUUVUVVVVVooooojj oojoj jj jjUj j UVVVj oU U U U UUUVVUVVVVVoooojj oojjj jojjV V jojj UVVj o V U oU j UUUVUUUVVVVooVoojj joooVVoo jj oU oooo V Uo V V U VUVjU UUUUUVoVVVoojj joo VoooV UVj o U VU o V U V U V UUUUUUVVVVoVooojj j V VooV UUUo UVj Vj U V VUVUU UUUUUVVVVVooj V ooo U UVj o V UUo VU j j U V VjUUVUUUUVVoVooojj Vj joooV V Uo U U jV UVj UV jU V UVoVoVooojj U j joooooooo Uoj V U U U Ujj V U V ojVUUUVoVoojj UV U o U V VUVVoooooooo Voj oVV V jV j U Vj UUUV U oVoVUV oVVoVoooj j V U UUUVVooojjooVo Uo VUU U oo o j oj o o U UoVooooj U UUUVooooooooVVVUo U Uo UV Uo V o oUUVVVojj oVUVVo U V V V UVooU UVVVUUooVo UUUU VoV VV U U jVVoooj j jjjj jjoooVV U V VUUVVVoooVUUUUUUVo j oV UUV U V V joVoojj jjoVj j VUUVVVooUUUUUUUUVUVoo VoV o jUV Vo U V V j o VV jVVVooj

MWM&K MWWWWWWWW& WWWWWWWWWWW W MWWWWWWK MW W WWWWWWWWW&&MKWW&WWW WWWWWWWWM&&K&WWWWMW WWWWWWWWM&MM&MWWK K W& &WWWWWWWWW&K &W WWWWWW&K W &K & K W WWWWWWWMK WW& MWW K K W WWWWMK WWMKK& K & K W WWK &WWWWM& M MW W &WWWWWW&KKKW WM W &WWWM M KWWWWWWW W& WWW K WW& W WWWWWWWWK MWK WWWW& K & K KK K MMK WWMM& MK WWWWWW& KW&M&&&&K & K & M&MWWWWM WWM&WW KWM&& M& & KK&MWWWW& WWWWWK KKMMWWWMWM K K& K&W& WWMMK M&&WMMW& WWM &K K M & WW&M &M&&&KMMMMWMK & K & & WW&KK K & KKKW & &&K K &WK M K& M K K K W& K K W K K K K W WW WWWKWWKWK WMWMW W WW& &WWMW& WWKWWWWMWWW MMWW WWWW

.,...,,:::::: :: : ,,, : . , . : :. ,,,.,,,: :,,: :: : . : ,:: , ,::,,,::::,,: :: : :, : :::,,:,:::,: : ,::,,,:::::: : : . ::,,.,,: :: , ::,,,,::::: ::,,,,,:: : , :::,,,,: :: . : : ::::: , , : ., : ::: :. . : , . . . . :. , : : ., : , : . , : : . : ,. :., .. :: :: , : , :,, , ,, , : :,., , : :. ::,.,: . , , . ::,..:: , : :. ::,..:: : . . : ::,.,: : . , . :,.., ::: :: : : ., : : , . ., . ,,,.,:::::,:::: : , ,. . : ,: . . ,,...,,,...,:,,: , ,: : .: ,, .: : , . ... ..: . . : :, :. : :: : .. . . . :

~ ~<<~~~ ~~<<<<*<~~<*<~ ~ ~ <~~~~ ~ ~ ~<<<<<~~<*****<~ ~<~ <* } < *<*<<~ ~ ~<<<<<<<**}}***~~<* < *****<~ ~~~ <*<*****}}}}}}*<~**~ * ~ < }*}}**~ ~<~~*}}*}*}}} }}}<<< ~ } }*~ ~ ~<<<<}}}*}}*}} }}<~ }< ~<*<*} }}}}*} }< ~ }< ~ ~<**} }}***} }*} ~ }< ~ <***} }}< *~~*} < ~ ~~~~<***} } * ~ ~~<**<**< }< ~ * ~~~~<*< ~ }** * ~< } ~ } < <<~~ * <} * * ~~ ~** ~ ~ * * <*<~~*}}}***}}}}} } }}< } < } } *<<~~<<<*<<<*** * ~ ~} }<<* }}< } } } } * } <*~ ~<<<*<<***}} ~~ < * < * * * } } <<~ <<**<<*}}} ~ * ~~ ~<<*<<*}*} } ~ ~~ * } < ~ ~~<<<<*}}} * } } } } } ~~~~~<***} * * **~ * } ~ < ~~~~<*<<} } ~ < * * < ~~ ~~<~<*< ~ } }<* < * < ~~~~~~~ ~<~ <} <* }~** * * ~ < ~~~~ ~ ~ *~}~ * ~ < < * } < } ~ ~ < < * } < *~ } < ~ < <~ < ~ } } ~ * * ~ } } < * ~ * } }}~ *}*} ~ < } ~ }} * <~ ~ *

j ooj oj Vj V Vj j o o jjj U o U V oj jj jjjj j ojjjj j jjjjjj U ooojj jjj jooojj Voojj jjj o jj UojU Uooojjj jojj jo U j V V V U VU VVVoooj j oU o o j V j V VVVVooj o joV j U U V joUVUooj V V VVojj V U U Vj oVoj Vo U UjoVoVoo Uo VUVV oVo j U Vo VUVUoV Uj o jo V jVo j o VUVU o j jo Uj U o j o jj V UV U V o oo joj o o o UUV U o j jo V UU U o VoU U V V jj V j j U UUVU Vojojoo j VV jjVV V o VU U V VVU j UVUV Uo UU V jV joUjj V V VjV jUUj VoUU o UU j j UV VVVj jj jV UUV U Uoo VV VU V oVo V U o jU UUVU VUV ooU j ooj j Uoo j V j U VVV o oVjj VVj jjV jj j VVjjoU jjjo j j V o j o U U U U